Canada Life vs Manulife: Compare Health Insurance Plans
Canada Life and Manulife are two of the three largest life and health insurers in the country, and their individual health products compete head to head in twelve provinces and territories. Canada Life concentrates everything under one Freedom to Choose brand with eight plans, three Guaranteed tiers for people leaving group benefits and five Select tiers for everyone else. Manulife splits seven plans across two distinct brands: FlexCare for anytime applicants and FollowMe for group conversions.
The practical differences are easy to state. Canada Life owns the high end of drug coverage, with Select Elite paying up to 250,000 dollars per person per year, two and a half times anything on the Manulife shelf. Manulife owns convenience: FlexCare plans include nine days of emergency travel coverage that Canada Life plans lack entirely, and FollowMe gives departing employees 90 days to enrol without medical questions versus the 60 days Canada Life allows.
At a glance
| Feature | Canada Life | Manulife |
|---|---|---|
| Provinces available | 12 provinces and territories (not offered in Quebec) | 12 provinces and territories (not offered in Quebec) |
| Plan options | 8 plans across 2 plan families | 7 plans across 2 plan families |
| Underwriting options | Guaranteed acceptance, Medically underwritten, Guaranteed issue | Guaranteed acceptance, Medically underwritten, Guaranteed issue |
| Plan tiers | Bronze, Silver, Gold, Platinum | Bronze, Silver, Gold, Platinum |
Benefit-by-benefit comparison
The summaries below come from the published plan documents for each carrier. Exact limits vary by tier, so treat these as the range you can expect across each lineup, then check the tier you would actually buy on our plans directory.
Drugs
- Canada LifeListed in 8 of 8 plans
- Covers brand and generic drugs alike. Select runs from 70 percent and a 500 dollar maximum up to Select Elite at 90 percent of the first 10,000 dollars and 100 percent of the next 240,000 dollars. Guaranteed tiers pay 80 to 90 percent up to 1,000 to 2,400 dollars, excluding smoking cessation and erectile dysfunction drugs.
- ManulifeListed in 7 of 7 plans
- Generic-only on most plans. FlexCare Starter caps at 525 dollars, Basic at 5,000 dollars with 70 percent reimbursement of the first 750 dollars, and Enhanced, the only tier covering brand name drugs, pays 90 then 100 percent up to 10,000 dollars. FollowMe pays 80 percent of generics up to 500 to 2,600 dollars by tier.
Routine Dental
- Canada LifeListed in 7 of 8 plans
- Select plans cover cleanings, fillings and exams at 70 to 80 percent, with maximums of 350 to 1,000 dollars and a 25 dollar per person annual deductible plus a three month no-claims wait. Guaranteed Plus and Elite pay 80 to 85 percent up to 1,000 to 2,000 dollars; the base Guaranteed tier covers dental accidents only.
- ManulifeListed in 5 of 7 plans
- FlexCare reimburses maintenance services at 70 to 100 percent of initial bands with basic maximums of 400 to 920 dollars and no deductible. FollowMe Enhanced Plus and Premiere pay 80 percent of basic and extensive services with maximums climbing from 700 or 800 dollars in year one to 1,000 or 1,500 dollars by year three.
Major Dental
- Canada Life
- Available on the Elite tiers: Guaranteed Elite covers crowns, dentures and related surgery at 50 percent up to 1,000 dollars per year, and Select Elite with dental pays 50 percent up to 750 dollars. Mid tiers like Guaranteed Plus exclude major work, and orthodontics is not offered anywhere in the lineup.
- Manulife
- FlexCare Starter and Basic exclude root canals, periodontics and major restorative entirely. FlexCare Enhanced phases in oral surgery and endodontics at 60 to 80 percent and major restorative at 60 percent from year two. FollowMe Premiere adds crowns, bridges, dentures and orthodontics at 60 percent starting in year two.
Vision
- Canada LifeListed in 8 of 8 plans
- All eight plans include vision: 100 percent reimbursement up to 150 to 250 dollars every two years for glasses, contacts or laser eye surgery, plus a 75 dollar eye exam allowance, the highest exam allowance in this comparison.
- ManulifeListed in 7 of 7 plans
- All seven plans include vision: 100 percent up to 150 to 300 dollars every two years plus 60 to 70 dollars toward optometrist visits, with FollowMe Premiere carrying the 300 dollar maximum.
Travel
- Canada LifeListed in 0 of 8 plans
- No emergency travel medical benefit appears in any Freedom to Choose plan document we publish. Canada Life buyers who travel need a separate travel policy.
- ManulifeListed in 3 of 7 plans
- FlexCare bundles five million dollars of emergency travel coverage per person for trips up to 9 days, with a 100 dollar deductible per claim and optional paid extensions of 8 or 21 days. FollowMe plans, like Canada Life, list no built-in travel benefit.
Paramedical
- Canada LifeListed in 8 of 8 plans
- Select plans pay 100 percent of paramedical visits up to combined annual maximums of 300 to 500 dollars, across one of the longest practitioner lists in the market: chiropractor, dietician, osteopath, physiotherapist, podiatrist, psychologist, social worker, massage therapist, speech therapist, naturopath and acupuncturist.
- ManulifeListed in 7 of 7 plans
- Registered specialist coverage spans chiropractors, chiropodists, osteopaths, naturopaths, podiatrists, massage therapists, acupuncturists and dietitians, with per person annual maximums and a 35 dollar chiropractic x-ray allowance each year.
Underwriting: how you qualify
Both insurers cover the full underwriting spectrum. For guaranteed acceptance with no medical questions at any time, Canada Life offers Select Guaranteed Acceptance with a 500 dollar drug maximum, and Manulife offers FlexCare ComboPlus Starter with a 525 dollar maximum, essentially a tie on entry terms. For medically underwritten applicants, Canada Life runs four Select tiers topping out at that 250,000 dollar drug ceiling, while Manulife runs two FlexCare tiers topping out at 10,000 dollars. For guaranteed issue after leaving a group plan, the deadlines diverge: Canada Life Freedom to Choose Guaranteed requires application within 60 days of group benefits ending, while Manulife FollowMe allows 90 days. If your benefits ended more than two months ago, Manulife may be the only one of these two still open to you without a health questionnaire.
New to these terms? See our plain-language guides to underwriting, pre-existing conditions, waiting periods and how your premium is set.
See real prices for your situation
Premiums for both carriers depend on your age, province and who is on the policy, so the fastest way to compare costs is a personalized quote. You can also estimate your out-of-pocket dental costs with our dental services calculator.
Frequently asked questions
My group benefits ended 70 days ago. Can I still get guaranteed issue coverage?
With Manulife, yes; with Canada Life, no. FollowMe accepts applications without medical questions for 90 days after employer coverage ends, while Canada Life Freedom to Choose Guaranteed closes its window at 60 days. At day 70 you could still enrol in any FollowMe tier, but with Canada Life you would need to pass medical underwriting for a Select plan.
Which insurer covers more in prescription drugs?
Canada Life, decisively, at the top end. Select Elite covers up to 250,000 dollars per person per year and includes brand name drugs across the Select line. Manulife peaks at 10,000 dollars on FlexCare ComboPlus Enhanced, and most other Manulife tiers reimburse generic drugs only with maximums between 500 and 2,600 dollars.
Does either carrier include travel insurance?
Only Manulife, and only on FlexCare. Those plans include five million dollars of emergency travel medical for the first 9 days of any trip, with a 100 dollar per claim deductible and optional 8 or 21 day extensions. Neither Canada Life Freedom to Choose nor Manulife FollowMe lists a built-in travel benefit.
How do their cheapest no-medical-questions plans compare?
They are strikingly similar on drugs and differ on dental mechanics. Canada Life Select Guaranteed Acceptance pays 70 percent of prescriptions to 500 dollars and routine dental at 70 percent to 350 dollars after a 25 dollar deductible. Manulife FlexCare Starter pays 70 percent of the first 575 dollars in dental at a 400 dollar maximum with a 525 dollar generic drug cap and no deductible.
Who should pick Canada Life over Manulife, and vice versa?
Pick Canada Life if drug exposure is your main risk, if you want a 75 dollar eye exam allowance, or if you value an unusually broad paramedical list that includes psychologists and social workers. Pick Manulife if you want travel coverage bundled in, a 90 day conversion deadline instead of 60, or orthodontics through FollowMe Premiere, which Canada Life does not offer at all.